Casey Rutherford
404.259.0548Milton resident and top-producing listing agent Casey Rutherford specializes in strategic home sales throughout Milton, Alpharetta, and North Atlanta's luxury market. Known for her data-driven pricing, refined presentation, and high-impact marketing, Casey delivers a sophisticated listing experience designed to protect her clients' equity and maximize value.
Before transitioning into real estate, Casey spent nearly a decade in corporate consulting, where she developed the analytical discipline and negotiation skills that now define her approach. She believes successful home sales are built on preparation, positioning, and precision, never guesswork.
Living in Milton with her husband Barry and their three children gives Casey a deep understanding of the community she represents. From neighborhoods and schools to lifestyle amenities, she offers clients both strategic insight and firsthand local knowledge.
Consistently recognized among the Atlanta REALTORS® Association's top producers and named the #1 individual agent in the Ansley North Atlanta office in 2024 and 2025, Casey pairs boutique-level service with the global reach and prestige of Ansley Real Estate | Christie's International Real Estate.
For Casey, representing a home is a responsibility and a privilege she approaches with intention, discretion, and unwavering commitment to results.
#1 Agent Ansley North (2024)
Ansley Real Estate Top Producer
Top 5% REALTOR
Atlanta Realtor Association
Influential Women of Atlanta
The Atlantan Magazine